AD: Mesquite GamingAD: MCJAD: GMAF

The most popular online news source, publishing news as it happens in Mesquite, Nevada. * 702.346.6432 * barbara@mesquitecitizen.com * Barbara Ellestad, Publisher * ALL Content Copyright 2011-2014

Thursday, April 24, 2014
MESQUITE NEWS 
SPORTS 
HIGH SCHOOL SPORTS 
OPINIONS 
WRITER'S CORNER 
COMMUNITY 
CONSUMER NEWS 
MARKETPLACE 
INTERACTIVE 

This week's poll

Has the NSA gone too far in its data collection efforts?

Yes, they need to stop
No, they are keeping us safe
I don't care

View Poll Report

 Keywords:
one or more words required
all words required
forced & ordered phrase
Multi forced & ordered phrase
words with exceptions
Help
 
 Issue date:
Date Format: dd-mm-yyyy

   
Arizona Game & Fish Opposes National Monument Designation
Posting Date: 06/12/2012

By Barbara Ellestad

A recent vote by the Arizona Game and Fish Commission could have an affect on the success or failure of current efforts to declare the Gold Butte area south of Mesquite as a National Conservation Area (NCA) with Wilderness.

The Commission voted to oppose designating 1.7 million acres in the northern section of the state as a Grand Canyon Watershed National Monument.

The proposal encompasses 1.7 million acres of mostly public land spread across five geographical areas: the Kaibab Plateau; Kaibab-Paunsagunt Wildlife Corridor; Kaibab Creek Watershed; House Rock Valley; and the Tusayan Ranger District, south rim headquarters.

The area is contiguous to the southern boundary of the current Gold Butte Area of Critical Environmental Concern (ACEC) and the Nevada/Arizona border.

According to a notice published on the Commission's Web site, "the vast majority of lands in question are already public lands currently managed and conserved under multiple-use concepts, primarily by the U.S. Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management." The Gold Butte ACEC is also managed by the BLM.

The nationally-recognized wildlife management organization also pointed to its own analysis that determined the monument designation could lead to restrictions on proactive management of wildlife including wildlife population augmentations, wildlife habitat manipulations and enhancements, wildlife water development and hunting and fishing access.

“It’s not as if these lands aren’t already being managed and conserved. This is really about changing the status of these lands and adding another layer of federal bureaucracy, which has far-ranging implications,” said Commissioner Kurt R. Davis.

Some of the issues the Commission cites in its opposition to the monument designation also exist in the discussion regarding the Gold Butte NCA designation, especially from those who are concerned about accessibility and multiple-use availability.

"The new monument is being proposed to “preserve” and in some cases lock away these lands rather than conserve them, which could impact public access, recreation, grazing, and the ability of the commission to manage wildlife," the Commission says.

"Once federal lands are converted to special use lands such as Wilderness and National Monuments, those lands permanently lose multiple-use provisions. In spite of organic legislation emphasizing multiple-use of public lands, neither the U.S. Forest Service or BLM have established any objectives for acreages of public lands to be maintained in full multiple-use," says the Commission's formal resolution opposing the National Monument.

Those who disagree with designating wide swaths of Gold Butte as Wilderness say similar outcomes could occur in the area with road closures and a prohibition on motorized and mechanized access.

The Friends of Gold Butte organization, a proponent advocacy group for designating Gold Butte as a National Conservation Area (NCA) with Wilderness says "there are no motorized access conflicts within the Citizens' Wilderness proposal."

Grazing rights in the Gold Butte area were pulled by Clark County in the 1990s. The lone remaining rancher in Clark County, Cliven Bundy, has been battling the BLM over grazing rights for his cattle for years. See

Mesquite Citizen Journal stories

The Arizona State Commission also cites "the continuing and cumulative effects that special land use designations have on multiple-use lands, including effects on access, conservation efforts and wildlife-related recreation."

Its resolution says that only 23 percent of Arizona lands remain open for public use and free from special land use designations.

The Gold Butte NCA designation would claim just over 350,000 acres. The Friends of Gold Butte organization has identified more than 120,000 acres within the NCA it wants designated as Wilderness. That would prevent any kind of access other than on foot.

The Clark County Conservation of Public Land and Natural Resources Act of 2002 designated 451,915 acres in the County as Wilderness.

The Partners in Conservation group, an advocacy group that opposes additional Wilderness designation in the Gold Butte area says that if a person draws a 100 mile circle around Mesquite, "that circle encompasses a little over 20 million acres with 16 million acres designated as monuments, wilderness, National Conservation Areas, Areas of Critical Environmental Concern, Refuges, military bases, national parks or state parks."

The Arizona State Commission says that the cumulative affect of declaring so many areas with special designations "has caused the systematic loss of recreational opportunities" and the erosion of the Department's ability to proactively manage wildlife.

"The department analysis points out that the loss of livestock management can cause significant loss of water availability for wildlife, besides negatively impacting the local economy."

Longtime residents in the Mesquite and Bunkerville area agree with that claim.

Cresent Hardy, lifetime area resident and Mesquite's State Assembly representative says that wildlife has suffered over the years as ranchers sold out their grazing rights and quit ranching much of the Gold Butte area.

"Wildlife depends on the water resource developments that ranchers built in the area over the years. As those watering spots went away, so did the wildlife," Hardy contends.

Bundy has been ordered by the BLM to remove all of his water management resources that he's built throughout the Gold Butte area over the years. He says that if his water resources go, so too will the wildlife.

The Utah State Legislature passed a bill earlier this year that would require the Federal government to give control of almost 30 million acres of land to the State. Governor Gary Herbert contends that his state wanting control of the lands is an economic development issue and gives the legislature more control over multiple use choices on public lands.

Arizona Governor Jan Brewer vetoed similar legislation last week for her state. The Arizona Bill would have required the Federal government to turn over approximately 23 million acres of land to the State. Brewer cited the cost of managing the land as her deciding factor against approval. She says it would cost the State approximately $23 million to manage the additional acreage.

Click here for full access to the Arizona Game and Fish Commission Resolution

 

Commentary
  • Posted Date: 06/12/2012
    Now we should listen to Arizona? a state that violates human rights, is racist, is being sued by the federal government for multiple abuses, gives tax breaks to the rich and has the worst environmental record in the west and now we are supposed to believe they care about the land? Arizona should mind their own business in Arizona. Look at all they have done for the AZ strip - nothing. Oh except try to get a toll road on I-15.
    By: Vic M
  •  
  • Posted Date: 06/12/2012
    Vic M,Once again you are MIS_INFORMED.
    By: Doug R
  •  
  • Posted Date: 06/12/2012
    both of you need ti spend time on getting a major business established here in Mesquite. 1st things 1st.
    By: elf
  •  
  • Posted Date: 06/12/2012
    Arizona is not racist and being sued by the criminal Eric Holder is a badge of honor. Tax breaks to the rich? My God, Vic M. what crazy things you believe in. Not one item is true. Shame on you. Enforcing their laws against criminal illegals is the RIGHT thing to do. At least they are not firing teachers like Clark County is doing. Wake up, sir.
    By: ralphedwards
  •  
  • Posted Date: 06/14/2012
    I take it that that Arizona has learned the hard way that once a wilderness designation is in place it will mean that ordinary citizens nor even state gov'ts. will ever have a say again. Not ever.
    By: A#1
  •  
     
    Name  
    Email  
    Opinion (2000 Characters)  
    Publish My Opinion    
     
    CAPTCHA Image
    Reload Image
     
     
    03/31/2014 - MCJ bids adieu
    03/31/2014 - Watson wears Ms. Sr. Mesquite Crown
    03/28/2014 - Mesquite Gaming bringing new events to town
    03/27/2014 - Three VVHS Students dead, two injured in DUI Collision
    03/27/2014 - BLM Land closed for Cattle Round-up
    03/26/2014 - Council delays Splash Pad project again - Video
    03/25/2014 - D-I-Y set for Bunkerville Secondary Water system change
    03/25/2014 - Cattle Roundup delayed again
    03/24/2014 - MSG Spells Athletic Fun and Fame for Seniors
    03/24/2014 - High School Mentors enjoy first-year success
    03/24/2014 - February Real Estate Closings continue drop-off
    03/21/2014 - Eureka proposes new community initiative program
    03/21/2014 - Mesquite City Manager addresses community concerns
    03/21/2014 - Lonetti gives Johnson, Coache water right ownership
    03/21/2014 - More construction starts Monday in Virgin River gorge
    03/20/2014 - Lonetti’s Water focus of VVWD lawsuits
    03/20/2014 - Jobs, economy, Obamacare on Congressional Candidate’s mind-Video
    03/19/2014 - Pioneer Blvd road repair starts soon-Video
    03/18/2014 - ‘Scammer Mom’ gets year in jail
    03/18/2014 - Innis speaks out on IRS scandal, racism-Video
    03/17/2014 - Innis weighs in on Energy, Gold Butte, Margins Tax-Video
    03/15/2014 - Power, Water Board Election Candidates finalized
    03/14/2014 - Republican Congressional Candidate Innis speaks out on issues – Part I
    03/13/2014 - Councilman Discusses Econ Development with Chamber-Video
    03/12/2014 - Mesquite eliminated from new warehouse business consideraton
    03/12/2014 - Council delays action on Union contract
    03/11/2014 - Another try at Cattle Round-up may be imminent
    03/10/2014 - February Building Permits double in value
    03/10/2014 - Man involved in MPD Shoot-out sentenced
    03/07/2014 - Theatre Group Cuts Capers in “Anything Goes”
    03/07/2014 - February Restaurant Review – Could your kitchen pass
    03/06/2014 - Mesquite is Mad About Movies
    03/06/2014 - Testimony reveals antics of former VVWD General Manager
    03/05/2014 - Start practicing 10-digit telephone dialing
    03/05/2014 - Water Board says No to most agenda items - Video
    03/05/2014 - Two Bulldogs make All-League, FitzSimons named Coach of the Year
    03/04/2014 - No wage hikes in new City Employee Union Contract
    03/04/2014 - City releases statement on Subdivision methane gas problem
    03/03/2014 - Mesquite January Visitor Volume soars like Hot Air Balloon
    03/03/2014 - Water District, Power District Election filings open today
    02/28/2014 - Old Mesquite Landfill Methane gas leaks threaten nearby homes
    02/27/2014 - Bridge improvement work progresses in I-15 Virgin River Gorge
    02/27/2014 - Mesquite City Council approves Recreation fee increases-Video
    02/27/2014 - Masterminding the Water District 2005 Water Share Purchase -Continuing Series
    02/26/2014 - Mesquite City Council approves new Bikeway Plan-Video
    02/26/2014 - MRBI future tabled by Mesquite City Council-Video
    02/26/2014 - Mesquite Honors Its Finest with Annual Awards-Video
    02/25/2014 - New Year brings slight dip in Mesquite real estate transactions
    02/25/2014 - Mesquite Building Permits get off to slow start in January
    02/25/2014 - Mesquite Teamsters Union Contract up for vote this week
    02/24/2014 - Flight School opens in Mesquite
    02/24/2014 - Mesquite Off-Road Weekend brings out the best-Video, Slideshows
    02/24/2014 - Mesquite Is All Action, Arts, and Elegance-Slideshow
    02/21/2014 - MCJ scores victories in all Court hearings
    02/20/2014 - Former VVWD Hydrologist admits ownership in water right trade
    02/19/2014 - VVWD Board approves Pioneer Blvd road repair -Video
    02/17/2014 - Mesquite Was All Heart during Valentine Week
    02/17/2014 - Mancuso celebrates 110th major milestone - Slideshow
    02/14/2014 - Suspect in Mesquite double murder pleads guilty
    02/14/2014 - Nevada AG rules against MRB in Open Meeting Law complaint
    02/13/2014 - Attention Business Owners - MRB has money for you - Video
    02/13/2014 - Mesquite Council approves RDA loan refinancing – Video
    02/12/2014 - Mesquite celebrates Annie’s 110 birthday - Video
    02/12/2014 - First Council to have actionable goals, Mesquite Mayor declares-Video
    02/11/2014 - Exploring Domestic Violence in Mesquite-Part II-Video
    02/10/2014 - Exploring Domestic Violence in Mesquite-Part I-Video
    02/10/2014 - One Ring Phone calls are the latest scam
    02/08/2014 - Beware of water insurance salesmen
    02/07/2014 - Restaurant inspections go well in January
    02/06/2014 - Plane crash averted, Pilot lands safely - Slideshow
    02/05/2014 - December Visitor Volume biggest jump in seven years
    02/04/2014 - 'Road to somewhere' denied, appeal process started
    01/31/2014 - City Manager, Attorney discuss supposed mayoral controversy
    01/30/2014 - New Adventure Park coming to Mesquite
    01/30/2014 - Taking Nominations for NV Senior Citizen of the Year
    01/29/2014 - Golf Tourney wins national award, Police Officers commended - Video
    01/29/2014 - Mesa View welcomes Family Medicine doctor to Mesquite
    01/29/2014 - December Real Estate transactions close out good year
    01/29/2014 - City Attorney addresses rumors, innuendoes from Mayor’s absence-Video
    01/28/2014 - Surprise announcements highlight Mesquite Business Preview - Video
    01/27/2014 - Head VVHS Football Coach stepping down
    01/27/2014 - Soccer swarms Mesquite - Slideshow
    01/27/2014 - Soaring high with Mesquite Hot Air Balloon Fest - Slideshow
    01/27/2014 - Crime Spree Ends With Two Arrests
    01/27/2014 - Motion granted MCJ to quash one set of subpoenas
    01/24/2014 - Hardy ready to announce Congressional candidacy – Part II
    01/23/2014 - Restrictions in Effect for I-15 Repaving Near Moapa Valley
    01/23/2014 - Hardy ready to announce Congressional candidacy – Part I
    01/13/2014 - A Magical Collaboration in Clay - Video
    12/23/2013 - Virgin River Gorge bridge improvements scheduled for I-15
    12/19/2013 - MCJ Editor Publisher slaps back at subpoenas in Water District lawsuits
    12/17/2013 - MCJ Editor Publisher slapped with six subpoenas in Water District lawsuit
    03/11/2013 - MCJ Sets New Policy for Article Comments

            Get our toolbar!