AD: Mesquite GamingAD: MCJAD: GMAF

The most popular online news source, publishing news as it happens in Mesquite, Nevada. * 702.346.6432 * barbara@mesquitecitizen.com * Barbara Ellestad, Publisher * ALL Content Copyright 2011-2014

Wednesday, April 23, 2014
MESQUITE NEWS 
SPORTS 
HIGH SCHOOL SPORTS 
OPINIONS 
WRITER'S CORNER 
COMMUNITY 
CONSUMER NEWS 
MARKETPLACE 
INTERACTIVE 

This week's poll

Has the NSA gone too far in its data collection efforts?

Yes, they need to stop
No, they are keeping us safe
I don't care

View Poll Report

 Keywords:
one or more words required
all words required
forced & ordered phrase
Multi forced & ordered phrase
words with exceptions
Help
 
 Issue date:
Date Format: dd-mm-yyyy

   
Modern Day Range Wars-Part IV-Closing Roads
Posting Date: 04/30/2012

By Barbara Ellestad

This is Part IV of a multi-part series examining the issues surrounding the Gold Butte controversy that's been going on for several years in the region. It is based on conversations with Nancy Hall, President of Friends of Gold Butte, and Elise McAllister, Director of Partners in Conservation, both 501(c) non-profit groups. Information based on conversations with Met Johnson, a long-time area resident and business owner, is also included in the series. This series is part essay, part opinion, and part news reporting.

See Mesquite Citizen Journal stories Modern Day Range Wars-Part I Modern Day Range Wars-Part II-Economic Impact and Modern Day Range Wars-Part III-Managing the Land

Don’t even think about joking around about road and trail closures when you discuss Gold Butte. Both sides of the issue tend to get a little touchy about that.

“For two years I’ve been advocating for 500 miles of roads to be legislated because that was a compromise [with the other side]. Then it would take an act of Congress to close any roads after that,” Hall said. “The lines for the citizen-proposed Wilderness were drawn around the roads designations. Any of the roads open right now would continue to be open.”

Hall contends that ATVs should not be allowed off the designated roads because of potential damage to the desert tortoise habitat and cryptobiotic soils.

“People are required to stay on the designated roads and trails and they have to keep their dogs on a lease. I understand it was different in the 1960s and different again in the 1980s. But those are the rules today,” she said.

That sounds reasonable until you consider past practices.

“Sloan Canyon [near Las Vegas] was supposed to have two roads left open on the back side of it,” McAllister explained when I asked her about the subject. “But, when the management plan came down, it said no off-highway vehicles. A lot of people in Vegas believed those roads would be left open but they weren’t. Now there aren’t any OHV roads there,” McAllister cautioned.

“NCA designations are for protection. They aren’t for multiple use. Every time there’s a step up in the designation, things get removed. We are fast becoming a ‘no multiple use’ land,” she added. “They’ve closed 47 miles of roads already. At one time, they proposed closing 25 percent of the roads in the ACEC.”

“Cherry stemming the roads around the wilderness designations like they have doesn’t mean the area has true wilderness characteristics,” McAllister said. “Cherry stemming seems disingenuous to me.”

“Plus,” she says, “you can be on a BLM road and not get a ticket. Then all of a sudden, you’re in a Park Service Wilderness area and you get a ticket. No one knows where that line is drawn. It makes it hard for people who want to do the right thing to actually do the right thing.”

“I don’t know how they can write the environmental assessment [regarding roads] into the NCA designation law because it contradicts BLM’s mandates that says BLM can close roads and areas if resources are impacted negatively,” McAllister continued. “Traditionally-used roads that were open before 1998 should still be open.”

The National Park Service did in fact close two very popular roads to motorized vehicles when it designated 91,000-plus acres near Lake Mead as a Wilderness.

That apparently is where serious doubts and disbeliefs enter into the picture on the part of those who want to leave the region as open as possible. People advocating keeping areas open to multiple uses feel that government agencies and conservation groups can’t be trusted to keep their original word.

"It's evident to me there's a big matter of trust through the years about what has been promised to this valley and what has really happened," Doug Reath, a Mesquite resident and avid ATV-er, said at the Mesquite City Council Technical Review when he spoke as a private citizen about the issue. He also serves as the government liaison for the Mesquite Chamber of Commerce.

"Once certain groups get a bite of the apple, they continue to go. The places I used to go to [in California] as a kid are absolutely shut down. I think negotiations have to take place to assure the community that that's not going to happen.

How Big is Gold Butte

The Gold Butte region can be one small tiny little area miles southwest of Bunkerville or it can be as far as the eye can see when you look at the mountain range and desert plateau south of Mesquite. How much is already designated wilderness and how much do conservation groups want to establish as a wilderness area?

Here are some

quick numbers to help put this into perspective – or not. It depends on who you talk to and which side of the fence they’re on.

Gold Butte proper is a tiny little area that was settled as a mining town around the late 1800s and early 1900s. McAllister related that it used to be “the place everyone from St. Thomas went to get gossip.” The town was on the Arrowhead Trail, an early road that led settlers and pioneers to and from California.

Now, most references to Gold Butte as a region encompass an area of over 300,000 acres, stretching from the south edge of Bunkerville clear over to Lake Mead and south to the Arizona border.

Hall says that “In the Clark County Conservation of Public Land and Natural Resources Act of 2002, 451,915 acres were designated as Wilderness. The Nevada Wilderness Coalition Citizen Proposal recognized more than 300,000 acres of wilderness quality lands in the Gold Butte area. Gold Butte received a fraction of this at less than 28,000 acres designated as Wilderness and 12,000 acres of Wilderness Study Area (WSA) released.”

Had the original request been met, the entire area would have, in effect, been shut down to all motorized vehicles, with only two feet as the authorized means of transportation. No improvements, changes or repairs to current structures would have been authorized in the entire area.

“The conservation advocates say they have already compromised because they revised their desired wilderness designation downward. We don’t want any wilderness but we’re already got some, so that’s our compromise,” McAllister remarked.

There are currently two locations designated as wilderness areas: Lime Canyon with 24,037 acres and Jumbo Springs with 4,631 acres. Million Hills WSA holds 22,579 acres with additions of 2,239.

Hall’s group, Friends of Gold Butte, and the Nevada Wilderness Coalition revised the wilderness request down to 107,013 under the “Citizen Proposed Wilderness.” The National Park Service has requested another 91,963 acres under its wilderness proposal. The Gold Butte NCA proposal includes a total of 348,515 acres according to Hall’s documents.

“If everything is declared ‘wilderness’ doesn’t ‘wilderness’ lose a special value,” McAllister asks.

A Clark County Commission resolution signed in May 2010 calls for 345,000 acres in the NCA and that 130,000 acres within that be designated as Wilderness. That’s in addition to the National Park Service Wilderness designation. Interestingly, neither resolution passed by the Mesquite City Council, one in 2009 and a replacement in 2010, designated a specific acreage for the NCA designation nor wilderness set asides.

Stewards of the land

Everyone agrees on one point. The Gold Butte tract is a beautiful area and requires stewardship on the part of everyone. Defining how that is carried out is where opinions differ.

Conservationists contend that protection at the federal level is the only way to protect the area. Other groups advocating to leave Gold Butte as an ACEC say it would allow more local control and input.

“We much prefer to have the local BLM office manage the area as an ACEC like it is now. Then we can sit down with them and work out conflicts rather than having laws written in Washington D.C.” McAllister commented.

“Site stewardship programs that were used in other areas in Clark County are gone after they were designated an NCA. Now there’s no real local control,” she added.

Johnson contends that the land is best cared for by those who have lived, worked, and played in the area their whole lives. He says that multiple uses of the area are the most important priority.

Longtime residents of Bunkerville and Mesquite also spoke out at the recent Mesquite City Council advocating for local control and stewardship saying they have been taking care of the area their whole lives. Others at the Council meeting disputed that citing the recent vandalism in the area.

One thing is for sure. The modern day range war raging over the Gold Butte area isn’t going away soon. Nevada’s Congressional delegation has promised to take up federal legislation that will surely displease one or both groups.

Hall has lived in Mesquite for 18 years and has worked with the Nevada Wilderness Project and other conservation groups for the last eight years. Friends of Gold Butte originated in Las Vegas in 2003 and was brought to Mesquite in 2006 when Hall became President. "After receiving my own grants in 2011, I became Executive Director," Hall explained. "We spun off from the Nevada Wilderness Project then."

Elise McAllister has lived in the Gold Butte region her whole life. She is the Director of Partners in Conservation and works on Gold Butte issues "when I have time." She is a 5th Generation resident of the Moapa Valley.

For more information about Gold Butte issues access these Web sites:

http://www.friendsofgoldbutte.org/

http://www.savegoldbutte.com/

 

Commentary
  • Posted Date: 04/30/2012
    "Johnson contends the land is best cared for by those that lived, worked and played there for their whole lives," but the facts show different. Those pioneers just used the land for their own benefit and did nothing with it. The locals have ignored it for 100 years. The only thing they did was use it to make money off it. So looking at the facts, Johnson is dead wrong.
    By: J Paul
  •  
  • Posted Date: 04/30/2012
    I think Kurt Sawyer is one of the leaders of Partners in Conservation too which means there is a lot of things going on behind the scenes that don't go public.
    By: Marilee@aol.com
  •  
  • Posted Date: 04/30/2012
    Yep Nevada the New California quess ill retire elsewhere
    By: pd
  •  
     
    Name  
    Email  
    Opinion (2000 Characters)  
    Publish My Opinion    
     
    CAPTCHA Image
    Reload Image
     
     
    03/31/2014 - MCJ bids adieu
    03/31/2014 - Watson wears Ms. Sr. Mesquite Crown
    03/28/2014 - Mesquite Gaming bringing new events to town
    03/27/2014 - Three VVHS Students dead, two injured in DUI Collision
    03/27/2014 - BLM Land closed for Cattle Round-up
    03/26/2014 - Council delays Splash Pad project again - Video
    03/25/2014 - D-I-Y set for Bunkerville Secondary Water system change
    03/25/2014 - Cattle Roundup delayed again
    03/24/2014 - MSG Spells Athletic Fun and Fame for Seniors
    03/24/2014 - High School Mentors enjoy first-year success
    03/24/2014 - February Real Estate Closings continue drop-off
    03/21/2014 - Eureka proposes new community initiative program
    03/21/2014 - Mesquite City Manager addresses community concerns
    03/21/2014 - Lonetti gives Johnson, Coache water right ownership
    03/21/2014 - More construction starts Monday in Virgin River gorge
    03/20/2014 - Lonetti’s Water focus of VVWD lawsuits
    03/20/2014 - Jobs, economy, Obamacare on Congressional Candidate’s mind-Video
    03/19/2014 - Pioneer Blvd road repair starts soon-Video
    03/18/2014 - ‘Scammer Mom’ gets year in jail
    03/18/2014 - Innis speaks out on IRS scandal, racism-Video
    03/17/2014 - Innis weighs in on Energy, Gold Butte, Margins Tax-Video
    03/15/2014 - Power, Water Board Election Candidates finalized
    03/14/2014 - Republican Congressional Candidate Innis speaks out on issues – Part I
    03/13/2014 - Councilman Discusses Econ Development with Chamber-Video
    03/12/2014 - Mesquite eliminated from new warehouse business consideraton
    03/12/2014 - Council delays action on Union contract
    03/11/2014 - Another try at Cattle Round-up may be imminent
    03/10/2014 - February Building Permits double in value
    03/10/2014 - Man involved in MPD Shoot-out sentenced
    03/07/2014 - Theatre Group Cuts Capers in “Anything Goes”
    03/07/2014 - February Restaurant Review – Could your kitchen pass
    03/06/2014 - Mesquite is Mad About Movies
    03/06/2014 - Testimony reveals antics of former VVWD General Manager
    03/05/2014 - Start practicing 10-digit telephone dialing
    03/05/2014 - Water Board says No to most agenda items - Video
    03/05/2014 - Two Bulldogs make All-League, FitzSimons named Coach of the Year
    03/04/2014 - No wage hikes in new City Employee Union Contract
    03/04/2014 - City releases statement on Subdivision methane gas problem
    03/03/2014 - Mesquite January Visitor Volume soars like Hot Air Balloon
    03/03/2014 - Water District, Power District Election filings open today
    02/28/2014 - Old Mesquite Landfill Methane gas leaks threaten nearby homes
    02/27/2014 - Bridge improvement work progresses in I-15 Virgin River Gorge
    02/27/2014 - Mesquite City Council approves Recreation fee increases-Video
    02/27/2014 - Masterminding the Water District 2005 Water Share Purchase -Continuing Series
    02/26/2014 - Mesquite City Council approves new Bikeway Plan-Video
    02/26/2014 - MRBI future tabled by Mesquite City Council-Video
    02/26/2014 - Mesquite Honors Its Finest with Annual Awards-Video
    02/25/2014 - New Year brings slight dip in Mesquite real estate transactions
    02/25/2014 - Mesquite Building Permits get off to slow start in January
    02/25/2014 - Mesquite Teamsters Union Contract up for vote this week
    02/24/2014 - Flight School opens in Mesquite
    02/24/2014 - Mesquite Off-Road Weekend brings out the best-Video, Slideshows
    02/24/2014 - Mesquite Is All Action, Arts, and Elegance-Slideshow
    02/21/2014 - MCJ scores victories in all Court hearings
    02/20/2014 - Former VVWD Hydrologist admits ownership in water right trade
    02/19/2014 - VVWD Board approves Pioneer Blvd road repair -Video
    02/17/2014 - Mesquite Was All Heart during Valentine Week
    02/17/2014 - Mancuso celebrates 110th major milestone - Slideshow
    02/14/2014 - Suspect in Mesquite double murder pleads guilty
    02/14/2014 - Nevada AG rules against MRB in Open Meeting Law complaint
    02/13/2014 - Attention Business Owners - MRB has money for you - Video
    02/13/2014 - Mesquite Council approves RDA loan refinancing – Video
    02/12/2014 - Mesquite celebrates Annie’s 110 birthday - Video
    02/12/2014 - First Council to have actionable goals, Mesquite Mayor declares-Video
    02/11/2014 - Exploring Domestic Violence in Mesquite-Part II-Video
    02/10/2014 - Exploring Domestic Violence in Mesquite-Part I-Video
    02/10/2014 - One Ring Phone calls are the latest scam
    02/08/2014 - Beware of water insurance salesmen
    02/07/2014 - Restaurant inspections go well in January
    02/06/2014 - Plane crash averted, Pilot lands safely - Slideshow
    02/05/2014 - December Visitor Volume biggest jump in seven years
    02/04/2014 - 'Road to somewhere' denied, appeal process started
    01/31/2014 - City Manager, Attorney discuss supposed mayoral controversy
    01/30/2014 - New Adventure Park coming to Mesquite
    01/30/2014 - Taking Nominations for NV Senior Citizen of the Year
    01/29/2014 - Golf Tourney wins national award, Police Officers commended - Video
    01/29/2014 - Mesa View welcomes Family Medicine doctor to Mesquite
    01/29/2014 - December Real Estate transactions close out good year
    01/29/2014 - City Attorney addresses rumors, innuendoes from Mayor’s absence-Video
    01/28/2014 - Surprise announcements highlight Mesquite Business Preview - Video
    01/27/2014 - Head VVHS Football Coach stepping down
    01/27/2014 - Soccer swarms Mesquite - Slideshow
    01/27/2014 - Soaring high with Mesquite Hot Air Balloon Fest - Slideshow
    01/27/2014 - Crime Spree Ends With Two Arrests
    01/27/2014 - Motion granted MCJ to quash one set of subpoenas
    01/24/2014 - Hardy ready to announce Congressional candidacy – Part II
    01/23/2014 - Restrictions in Effect for I-15 Repaving Near Moapa Valley
    01/23/2014 - Hardy ready to announce Congressional candidacy – Part I
    01/22/2014 - Water Board approves emergency pump repair
    01/13/2014 - A Magical Collaboration in Clay - Video
    12/23/2013 - Virgin River Gorge bridge improvements scheduled for I-15
    12/19/2013 - MCJ Editor Publisher slaps back at subpoenas in Water District lawsuits
    12/17/2013 - MCJ Editor Publisher slapped with six subpoenas in Water District lawsuit
    03/11/2013 - MCJ Sets New Policy for Article Comments

            Get our toolbar!